Skip to main content

A Defense Medical Examination in a Virginia Injury Lawsuit: Preparing for the Appointment

Home  /  Blog  /  A Defense Medical Examination in a Virginia Injury Lawsuit: Preparing for the Appointment
A Defense Medical Examination in a Virginia Injury Lawsuit: Preparing for the Appointment

A letter scheduling a medical examination during an injury lawsuit can be confusing, especially when you already have treating doctors. Start by sending the complete letter and attachments to your attorney. Identify who requested the appointment and whether there is a court order or an agreement governing it.

An opposing-party examination serves a litigation purpose. Calling it an “independent medical examination” does not mean the examiner is your treating clinician or was jointly selected by both sides.

Check the request against Rule 4:10 and the actual order

Virginia Supreme Court Rule 4:10(a) allows a court, on an adverse party’s motion, to order an examination when a party’s physical or mental condition is in controversy. The rule requires good cause and notice. An order must identify the examiner and specify the examination’s time, place, manner, conditions, and scope, as well as the timing for the report and copies.

Those requirements make the particular documents important. A scheduling letter should not be treated as permission for every possible test or topic. Equally, do not ignore an order or decide on your own that the appointment is optional. Ask your attorney to address questions or requested changes before the examination.

Resolve practical issues before the appointment

  • Confirm the location, start time, expected duration, and transportation plan.
  • Identify language, mobility, or other access needs early.
  • Ask what records, medication list, identification, or assistive devices to bring.
  • Clarify questions about forms, testing, observers, and any proposed recording.
  • Ask whom to call if the examiner, location, or planned procedure changes.

Do not assume that you may record the examination, bring an observer into the room, or substitute another appointment. Have counsel review those questions against the applicable order or agreement. If a form arrives in advance, send it to your attorney instead of waiting until you are in the waiting room.

Prepare to describe your condition accurately

Review your own timeline so you can distinguish symptoms before the crash, changes afterward, treatment, and current limitations. Use ordinary descriptions. If you do not remember a date or medical term, say so rather than guessing.

Explain changes and variability honestly. For example, the ability to perform an activity once may differ from the ability to repeat it throughout a workday. Do not minimize an actual limitation, exaggerate a symptom, or rehearse a false demonstration. Do not alter medication or treatment to affect the examination; direct medical questions to your treating clinician.

If an activity causes pain or you do not understand an instruction, communicate that clearly. If an unexpected issue arises, contact your attorney through the agreed process. Preparation should make the account more accurate, not manufacture evidence.

Write down concerns afterward and discuss the report

After the appointment, make a factual note of the duration, people present, activities performed, and any problem or change you noticed. Separate observations from conclusions about why the examiner acted a certain way. Give the note to your lawyer; do not post accusations or details of the litigation publicly.

Ask counsel how the report will be obtained and evaluated, including any material factual error. An examiner’s opinion is part of the litigation record, not a reason to stop needed treatment or assume the case has been decided. Our deposition preparation guide covers a different discovery event, and our claim-process guide places these steps in context.

Talk with Phoenix about your next step

The Phoenix Trial Firm handles car-accident injury matters in Hampton Roads. Call 757-777-9285 or request a consultation. Spanish-speaking staff can assist with inquiries and consultations.

This article provides general information, not advice about a particular case. Contacting the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship; representation requires an agreement.

Talk with our team

Tell us what happened, or call 757-777-9285.

An inquiry does not create an attorney-client relationship; representation requires our agreement. Please wait for instructions before sending confidential or time-sensitive material.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
I Have Read The Disclaimer*

Copyright © 2026 The Phoenix Trial Firm• All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy. Digital Marketing By: rizeup media logo